IBC vs SARFAESI vs DRT: which recovery route fits which case

By Alok Sinha Published Updated 6 min read

In short

Indian law gives lenders several ways to recover money: insolvency under the IBC, enforcement of security under the SARFAESI Act, recovery applications before the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT), civil suits, and arbitration. Each has different users, forums and appeal routes. Which one fits depends on whether the lender is secured, who the lender is, the size of the debt, and whether the aim is to recover money or to resolve the borrower's business.

The five routes at a glance

Route Main law Who can use it Forum What it does Appeal
Corporate insolvency (CIRP) IBC, 2016 – Section 7 Financial creditors (banks, NBFCs, ARCs, debenture holders, other lenders) NCLT Starts a collective process to resolve the company; moratorium on other actions NCLAT, then Supreme Court
Enforcement of security SARFAESI Act, 2002 – Section 13 Secured creditors covered by the Act (banks, financial institutions, notified NBFCs, ARCs) No court needed to start; borrower can go to the DRT Take possession of and sell secured assets DRT (s.17), DRAT (s.18), High Court (writ)
Recovery application RDB Act, 1993 – Section 19 Banks and financial institutions Debts Recovery Tribunal Recovery certificate executed by the Recovery Officer DRAT (s.20), High Court (writ)
Civil or commercial suit Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Commercial Courts Act, 2015 Any creditor Civil court or Commercial Court Money decree, then execution Appeal under the CPC / Commercial Courts Act
Arbitration Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Parties to an arbitration agreement Arbitral tribunal; court for enforcement Arbitral award enforced like a decree (s.36) Challenge under s.34, appeal under s.37

1. Insolvency under the IBC

A financial creditor can apply to the NCLT under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 when a company defaults on a financial debt at or above the notified minimum (₹1 crore since March 2020).

If the NCLT admits the application, three things follow:

  • a moratorium under Section 14 stops most suits, recovery actions and enforcement of security against the company;
  • an insolvency professional takes over the management of the company;
  • the Committee of Creditors (CoC), made up of financial creditors, decides whether to approve a resolution plan. Approval needs at least 66% of the voting share.

The Code sets a time limit of 180 days, extendable once by up to 90 days, with an outer limit of 330 days including litigation. If no plan is approved, the company may be liquidated, and money is paid out in the order set by Section 53.

2026 changes. The IBC (Amendment) Act, 2026 received assent on 6 April 2026, and many of its provisions came into force on 25 May 2026. It sets clearer grounds for admitting Section 7 applications, limits withdrawal of a CIRP, sets liquidation timelines and introduces a creditor-initiated insolvency resolution process for notified classes of companies. Check which provisions are in force on the relevant date.

Most useful when: the borrower is a company, the default is large, several creditors are involved, and a restructuring or sale of the business as a going concern is realistic.

2. Enforcement under the SARFAESI Act

The SARFAESI Act, 2002 lets a secured creditor enforce its security without first going to court.

  1. The creditor classifies the account as a non-performing asset and sends a demand notice under Section 13(2), giving the borrower 60 days to pay.
  2. If the borrower does not pay, the creditor can take measures under Section 13(4) – for example, taking possession of the secured asset and selling it.
  3. The borrower (or any affected person) can challenge the measures before the DRT under Section 17, usually within 45 days. A further appeal lies to the DRAT under Section 18, with a pre-deposit.

The Act does not apply in some cases listed in Section 31 – for example, security over agricultural land, or where the amount due is less than 20% of the principal and interest.

Most useful when: the lender is covered by the Act, the security is clear and saleable, and the lender wants to realise that security rather than resolve the whole business.

3. Recovery before the Debts Recovery Tribunal

Under the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993, banks and financial institutions can file an application before the DRT to recover debts of the minimum amount (₹20 lakh and above). The DRT can issue a recovery certificate, which the Recovery Officer enforces by attaching and selling assets.

An appeal lies to the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal (DRAT). A borrower who appeals must usually deposit part of the amount, which the DRAT may reduce.

Most useful when: the lender is a bank or financial institution, the borrower may be an individual or a firm (not only a company), and the lender wants a money decree that covers all of the borrower's assets.

4. Civil or commercial suit

Lenders that cannot use SARFAESI or the DRT – for example, many funds and private lenders – can file a civil suit for recovery. Where the claim is based on a written contract or a negotiable instrument, a summary suit under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure can be quicker. Commercial disputes above the specified value go to Commercial Courts, which require pre-institution mediation in most cases where no urgent relief is sought.

Most useful when: other routes are not available, the borrower is not a company, or the lender needs urgent court orders such as an injunction.

5. Arbitration

If the loan documents contain an arbitration clause, the dispute goes to an arbitral tribunal. A party may ask a court for interim measures under Section 9 – for example, to protect assets – before or during the arbitration. The final award can be challenged under Section 34 and, once the time for challenge is over, is enforced like a court decree under Section 36.

Most useful when: the documents require arbitration, one party is foreign, or confidentiality matters.

How to choose: five questions

  1. Is the debt secured? If yes, and the lender is covered, SARFAESI may be the first step.
  2. Who is the lender? Banks and financial institutions have the widest choice. Many funds rely on the IBC, civil suits or arbitration.
  3. Who is the borrower? The CIRP applies only to corporate debtors. For individuals and firms, the DRT, a civil suit or arbitration is more common.
  4. What is the aim? To recover money from specific assets, or to resolve the borrower's whole business with other creditors?
  5. What is already happening? If another creditor has started a CIRP, the moratorium will affect every other route.

The routes are not always exclusive. A lender may send a SARFAESI notice, file before the DRT, and still decide later to apply under the IBC. Each step has consequences for the others, so the order matters.

This article explains the law in general terms. It is not legal advice on any particular case and is not a recommendation about any investment.

Common questions

Can a bank use SARFAESI and the IBC at the same time?

A secured creditor can take SARFAESI steps and also apply under the IBC. But once the NCLT admits an insolvency application, the moratorium under Section 14 of the IBC generally stops enforcement of security, including SARFAESI action, while the CIRP lasts.

Can a debt fund or AIF use SARFAESI or the DRT?

Usually only if it falls within the classes of lenders those Acts cover, or holds the debt through an entity that does, such as an asset reconstruction company. A fund that holds debentures can generally act as a financial creditor under the IBC. The answer depends on the fund's structure and the debt documents.

Is the IBC a recovery tool?

The Supreme Court has said that the IBC is mainly a law for resolving insolvency, not a recovery mechanism. In practice creditors often recover money through a resolution plan or settlement, but the process is collective and controlled by the Committee of Creditors.

Which route is fastest?

There is no single answer. SARFAESI can move quickly where the security is clear, because it does not need a court order to start. IBC timelines are fixed by law but are often extended by litigation. DRT and civil suits depend on court workload.

Laws and official sources (7)
Alok Sinha

Alok Sinha

Advocate, Supreme Court of India. Founder and President of ASC Solicitors & Advocates and President of the Bhartiya Legal Support Foundation.

Disclaimer

The Bar Council of India does not permit advocates to solicit work or advertise. By clicking "I agree", you confirm that:

ASC provides legal services only. Nothing on this website is investment, financial or tax advice, or a recommendation to invest.

Full text: Disclaimer